Comparison of Skeptical Interpretation with Naturalistic Interpretation of the Philosophy of Hume

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

Hāshim Murvārīd

‘Alī Ḥaqqī

10.22067/philosophy.v41i1.3181

Abstract

Was Hume really a skeptic empiricist? The common picture that existed about Hume sometime ago outlined him as an empiricist who, contrary to his preceding empiricists, could deduce skepticism which was a corollary of empiricism from it. According to this interpretation, Hume's entire project is negation and rejection of metaphysical knowledge as well as a science based on
principles of empiricism. However, in the first half of twentieth century, David Camp Smith presented a more positive interpretation of Hume. According to his interpretation, Hume's objective is not entirely negating and rejecting; rather, his prime purpose is to indicate that man's fundamental beliefs, which according to the principles of empiricism are not adoptable from experience or intellect, are originated from human nature, and, somehow, the nature imposes them on us. This analysis by Smith transforms Hume from a skeptic empiricist into a naturalist philosopher. The present paper seeks to make a brief comparison between these two interpretations on Hume.

Keywords

philosophy of Hume

empiricism

skepticism

naturalism

fundamental beliefs

---

References

راسل، برتراند؛ تاریخ فلسفةغرب، ترجمةدریابندری، تهران، نشر پرواز، 1365، جلد دوم.

Dicker, Georges, Hume’s Epistemology And Metaphysics, USA, Routledge, 1998.

Green, Thomas Hill, Introductions to Hume’s Treatise of Human Knowledge, 1874

Hume, David, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, London, Oxfor University Press, 1975.

Hume, David, A Treatise of Human Nature, Oxford, The clarendon Press, 1978.

Macknabb, D.G.C., David Hume, Encyclopedia of philosophy of poul Edwards, 1967 , volume4.

Mounce, H.O., Hume’s Naturalism, USA, Routledge, 1999.

Norton, David fate, Editor’s introduction to A Treatise concerning Human Nature, Oxford, Oxford university press, 1996.

Norton, David fate, An Introduction to Hume’s Thought, The Cambridge Companion to Hume, USA, Cambridge university press, 1993.

kemp Smith,N..”The Naturalism of Hume” I, in Mind, 1904 reprinted in David Hume: Critical Assessments. Ed. by Stanley Tweyman, London, Routlegde, 2002.

kemp Smith, N.. “The Naturalism of Hume” II, in Mind, 1908 reprinted in David Hume: Critical Assessments, Ed. by Stanley Tweyman, London, Routlegde, 2002.

Stroud, Barry, Hume, London, Routledge and kegan Paul Plc, 1977.

Watkins, John, Science and scepticism, USA, Princton university Press, 1989.