Analogy of Aquinas and its Comparison to Graded Universal

Document Type : Original Article

Author

• Ghulām Ḥusayn Tawakkulī

10.22067/philosophy.v40i2.3171

Abstract

Most theologians, either Muslim or Christian, have sought to find a way in which an undersanding, however incomplete, of God
would be possible. The Muslim philosophers have brought up
gradational predicates and Saint Thomas Aquinas maintains that
attributes are analogically attributed to God which is a borderline
between the homonym and the univocal. With reference to
various sources, the present article explicates the viewpoint of
Aquinas in respect to analogy, then compares it with the current viewpoint of the Islamic philosophy, and finally critically reviews and evaluates it. It will further be noticed that the insistence on the subsumption of the analogy under homonym will leave the problem unresolved and understanding the attributes will still remain impossible; however, acceptance of a single meaning and admitting to its firmness and infirmity will not leave much of a difference between the analogy and equivocal predication common in Islamic philosophy.

Keywords

• analogy: homonym: univocal: univocal universal: graded universal

---

References

1. ابن سینا، حسین عبدالله (370-428ق)؛ الاشارات و التنبیهات مع الشرح للمحقق نصیرالدین طوسی، جلد سوم، دفتر نشر کتاب، تهران، 1379.

   ابن سینا، حسین عبدالله (370-428ق)؛ الالهیات من کتاب الشفاء، تحقیق آیة الله حسن زاده آملی، مرکز انتشارات دفتر تبلیغات، قم، 1376.

   ابن سینا، حسین عبدالله (370-428ق)؛ المنطق من کتاب الشفا، ج 1، منشورات مکتبة آیة الله العظمی المرعشی النجفی، قم، 1405.

   ارسطو،(384-322ق.م.)؛ مابعد الطبیعه، ترجمه شرف الدین خراسانی، نشر گفتار، تهران،1367.

   خوانساری، محمد؛ منطق صوری، مؤسسه انتشارات آگاه، تهران،1367.

   ژیلسون ، اتین(1884-1978م.)؛ تومیسم، در آمدی بر فلسفه قدیس توماس آکویناس، ترجمه سید ضیاء الدین دهشیری، انتشارات حکمت، تهران،1384.

   ژیلسون؛ روح فلسفه در قرون وسطی، ترجمه علیمراد داودی، نتشارات علمی فرهنگی، تهران.

   صـدرالدین شیرازی، محمـدبن ابراهیم(979-1050ق.)؛ منطق نوین، با ترجمـه و شرح

   دکتر عبدالمحسن مشکوه الدین، مؤسسه انتشارات آگاه، تهران، 1362.

   .Aristotle,(1995) metaphysic, in: Commentary on Aristotle metaphysics, Domb Ox Books, Notre Dame, Indiana.

   Aquinas. Thomas, (1995) Commentary on Aristotle metaphysics, Domb Ox Books, Notre Dame, Indiana.

   Aquinas, Thomas, (1981) ‘The Summa Theologica’, Trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Providence. Christian Classics Press.

   Aquinas, Thomas, (1991) ‘The Summa Contra gentiles’ University of Notre Dame Press; Rpt edition.

   Davies .Brian,(2000) Philosophy of Religion a Guide and Anthology, Oxford

   university press, New Yourk.

   Ashworth.E. Jennifer,(1991) ‘Medieval Theories of Analogy’, ‘Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy’ stanford university Press . also available: substantive, (http://plato. stanford. edu/entries/analogy-medieval

   Bourke. Vernon J (1972), Thomas Aquinas.St In: Encyclopedia of philosophy ed: Poal Edwards, Vol 8, Collier Macmillan Publishing,London.

   Capleston F.C(1955) Aquinas, Harmondsworth, Middlsex, Penguin Books.

   Davies .Brian,(2002)  Aquinas an Introduction, Oxford university press.

   Davies .Brian,(2003)  Aquinas on what God is Not in: Thomas Aquinas, ed by Davies .Brian, Oxford university press.

   Hick.John(1965) Religious Pluralism in: The philosophy of Religion Reader, Ed: Chad Meister, Rutledge, London.

   Lucas,John, (1989) The Future, Oxford University Press.

   McCabe O.P,(1964) Appendix 4 to the vol 3 of Summa Theologica, London  and

   New York.

    Owen. H P, “God ,Concept of” In: Encyclopedia of philosophy ed: Poal Edwards, Vol 7, Collier Macmillan Publishing,London.

   Plantinga. Alvin (1984) “Advice to Christian Philosophers” In: faith and philosophy

   stump. Eleonore (2005) Aquinas, Rutledge

   Swinburne .Richard(1994) The Christian God, Oxford University Press, Inc ,New york.

   Swinburne .Richard(1993) The Coherence of Deism, Oxford University Press

   27. Stephen, A. Richards, (1999) Religious Language: An Introduction”

   http://www.faithnet.org.uk/A2%20Subjects/Philosophyofreligion/language.htm

   28. Strumia. Alberto, (1998) “Analogy, in Encyclopedia of Religion and science Ed by G.Tanzella and A Strumia, Open Court Publishing Company, Chicago also available on: http://www.disf.org/en/Voci/29.asp

   Polities. Vasilis(2004)Aristotel and the Metaphisics,Routledge ,London and New York.